Jump to Recipe Print Recipe
Scotty Boxa

Cocksucking Cowboy Shot

5 from 1 vote
The Cocksucking Cowboy Shot is one of those drinks that gets people talking before they even take a sip. A smooth and dangerously delicious blend of butterscotch schnapps and Irish cream, this shot is pure liquid gold. Sweet, creamy, and ridiculously easy to throw back, it’s a party favorite that delivers big on flavor with minimal effort.
Some call it a Buttery Nipple, others just call it damn tasty. No matter the name, one thing’s for sureβ€”this shot goes down easy and leaves you wanting another round.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 3 minutes
Total Time 5 minutes
Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients
 

  • 3/4 oz Butterscotch Schnapps
  • 1/4 oz Irish Cream

Instructions
 

Pour Butterscotch Schnapps:
  1. Pour 3/4 oz of butterscotch schnapps into a shot glass.
Add Irish Cream:
  1. Carefully add 1/4 oz of Irish cream, letting it float on top of the schnapps.
Serve:
  1. Serve immediately and enjoy the sweet, smooth flavors.

Notes

Taste Profile: What Does the Cocksucking Cowboy Shot Taste Like?

This shot is a dream for anyone with a sweet tooth. The Cocksucking Cowboy Shot brings a dominant, rich butterscotch flavor, complemented perfectly by the smooth, slightly boozy vanilla tones of Irish cream. Think liquid butterscotch candy or a creamy dessert that slides down effortlessly. It’s sweet, indulgent, and not overly strong, making it one of the most approachable shots out there.

Cocksucking Cowboy Shot Variations & Fun Twists

The classic is unbeatable, but hey, mixology is about creativity! Try these tasty spins:
  • Cream Liqueur Swap: Switch out Irish Cream for a chocolate cream liqueur for a chocolate-butterscotch dream.
  • Whipped Cream Finish: Go dessert-level decadent with a dollop of whipped cream and a sprinkle of cocoa or cinnamon.
  • Temperature Play: Ice-cold for a refreshing hit, or room temp for deeper, richer flavor.
  • Party Garnish: Tiny cowboy hat or boot as a themed garnish? Absolute party legend.

When to Serve the Cocksucking Cowboy Shot?

This sweet, creamy shooter is perfect for:
  • Parties & Celebrations: A cheeky name and decadent taste make it a guaranteed crowd-pleaser.
  • Dessert Shots: The perfect boozy dessert alternative.
  • Holiday Gatherings: Sweet and cozy flavors for festive vibes.
  • Any Fun Night: When you want easy, tasty, and just a little bit naughty.
(As always, drink responsibly, legends.)

Essential Gear for This Sweet Shot

You don’t need a fancy setup, just the basics:
  • Shot Glass (1.5–2 oz): Shows off those gorgeous layers.
  • Bar Spoon: Layering pro tip, pour slow and steady.
  • Jigger or Measuring Spoons: Because precision matters for flavor and presentation.

Cocksucking Cowboy Shot FAQs

Q: What’s in it?
A: The classic recipe uses ΒΎ oz Butterscotch Schnapps and ΒΌ oz Irish Cream, layered to perfection.
Q: How do you layer it?
A: Start with the butterscotch schnapps. Slowly pour Irish Cream over the back of a spoon so it floats, voila, layers done right.
Q: Is it strong?
A: Not really. At around 15–20% ABV, it’s one of the milder shots, smooth and easy to sip.
Q: What does it taste like?
A: Like a creamy, boozy butterscotch candy. Sweet, indulgent, and dangerously easy to love.
Q: Can I swap Irish Cream?
A: Yep, try other cream liqueurs, just make sure they’re similar in density for layering success.

Loved This Shot? Mix Up More Magic!

If you enjoyed this sweet and cheeky little shooter, you’ll love what’s inside my full cocktail collection. More recipes, more twists, more excuses to call yourself a mixology master.
Servings: 1 serving
Course: Beverage, Cocktails, Drinks, Shot
Cuisine: Beverage, Cocktail, Drinks, Shot
Calories: 78
Cheers Mate! Cocktail Recipes book cover by Scotty Boxa, featuring a shaker and glass
Grab it here

Cheers Mate!
Your ultimate cocktail playbook. Over 100 drinks that’ll make you the life of the party (or at least your own kitchen).

weets & Treats Dessert Recipes book cover by Scotty Boxa, featuring cupcakes and ice cream
Snag it now

Sweets & Treats
Boozy desserts + classic indulgence = pure chaos in the best way. No-bake cheats, rich bakes, and grown-up sweets you won’t want to share.

You Might also like these Recipes

Cocksucking Cowboy Shot

The Cocksucking Cowboy Shot! Our easy recipe crafts a unique, creamy layered shooter with KahlΓΊa, Baileys & whipped cream. Perfect for parties! Get the guide.

Cactus Cooler Bomb Shot Recipe

Get the recipe for the Cactus Cooler Shot, a high-energy bomb shot that's a fun, fizzy, and fruity party starter. This guide shows you how to make this delicious drink.

Strawberry Daiquiri

Get the recipe for the Strawberry Daiquiri, a frozen classic of white rum, fresh lime, and ripe strawberries. This guide shows you how to blend the ultimate summer crowd-pleaser.

JAPANESE SEX COCKTAIL

Sweet, fruity, and exotic the Japanese Sex Cocktail. It's as tropical as a beach getaway and smooth enough to rival your best late-night rendezvous.

Vodka Infused Watermelon

Get the recipe for Vodka-Infused Watermelon, a classic summer party trick that’s fun to make and delicious to eat. This guide shows you how to make this boozy, refreshing treat.

Mexican Bulldog Cocktail

Get the recipe for the Mexican Bulldog, a legendary cocktail that's a brilliant mashup of a frozen margarita and a Mexican beer. This is one part fun, two parts delicious, and perfect for your next fiesta.

Blue Long Island Iced Tea

Get the recipe for the Blue Long Island Iced Tea, a vibrant blue cocktail that’s a powerful and fruity twist on the classic. This guide shows you how to make this legendary party drink.

cocktail in golden hour outdoor setting
Buttery Nipple Shot

A two-ingredient layered shot that drinks like a butterscotch caramel candy in liquid form. Butterscotch schnapps on the bottom, Baileys floated on top.

Panty Dropper Shot Recipe

Looking for a legendary party shot? This guide provides the ultimate recipe for the Panty Dropper, a sweet and fruity shot that's guaranteed to be a crowd-pleaser.

More Bad Decisions From Behind the Bar

I’m Scotty Boxa. Australian author, professional bad decision maker, and the bloke responsible for the rest of this website.

If this recipe made you laugh, you’ll like the rest of what I do. I write books that are mostly true stories about cocktails, travel, and the disasters that come with both. If you want a starter pack, grab the free PDF below. No email required, just take it.